Self-Sufficiency is Important for All Families
By Sue Voyles
Family Service, Detroit, MI

Reprinted with permission from Focus, Spring 2002, a publication of Family Service, Inc., Detroit, Michigan,

Within the context of a family, the term “self-sufficiency” has different connotations. For some families, it means that their baby has learned to walk on his or her own. For others, it means their teenage children have learned to drive. And for some families, it means breaking the cycle of poverty — holding down a good job or earning enough to achieve the American dream of owning a home.

Within the framework of economic self-sufficiency, there have been difficult times for American families. During the Depression era of the 1930s, breadwinners found themselves out of work and their families on the verge of hunger, homelessness and hopelessness.

Government programs created during this time supported families who were struggling to maintain self-sufficiency. One such initiative was public housing.

“From my knowledge, public housing was begun to assist the worst victims of the Depression. Residency was to be temporary until people got on their feet. It was expected that eventually, everyone would have to work and move on,” explained Patsy Fletcher, a Community Development Consultant based in Washington, D.C. and formerly with the Washington, D.C. Public Housing Authority.

Today, public housing still exists, now serving the working poor, the unemployed, female-headed households and others who need support. Helping these families attain economic self-sufficiency through good-paying jobs, homeownership, entrepreneurship and wealth accumulation is fraught with challenges.

While not a public housing resident, Yolanda Simmons, understands well the challenge of achieving self-sufficiency. While she was in a job training program, the Detroit resident sought help from Family Service’s Program Division three years ago.

“I was having housing issues. My landlord was not maintaining the property and I was behind in my bills,” said Simmons, a mother of three boys and three girls, ages 16 to 10.

FS Program Manager Carl Herrell moved into action, linking Simmons into the Agency’s Wraparound program. Wraparound offers a variety of services to at-risk youth and their families. Herrell helped Simmons find a new residence and arranged for payment of the first and last month’s rent. He also counseled and encouraged her to become self-sufficient.

“Carl taught me how to think for myself and be confident in my decision-making,” commented Simmons. “Whatever I needed help with, he was someone I could talk to. He showed me how to push myself a little more and not to give up when I’m scared.”

Part of Simmons’ journey to self-sufficiency included clerical training at the Reemployment Transition Center (RTC) in Detroit. After working six months at the Center, she was hired on a part-time basis. That was three years ago, and she enjoys the work tremendously.

“I’m a clerical support staff person and I also act as a community resource person, attending job fairs and speaking,” said Simmons. She has spoken to the FS Alternative Intervention Method (A.I.M.) program clients about RTC’s Partnership Adult Learning program that provides computer and literacy skills.

Family Service’s success with Simmons and other clients in the Wraparound and A.I.M. programs recently led to another opportunity to help families achieve self-sufficiency. FS was awarded a contract by the Detroit Housing Commission to provide case management services to current and former residents of Jeffries Homes and Herman Gardens.

“As the lead agency, FS provides a single point of entry to link families to the variety of programs and services residents need in order to successfully manage their lives,” stated Barbara Fahrenkrug, Vice President, FS Program Division.

The HOPE VI Program (Housing Opportunities to People Everywhere) was created in 1992 by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), as a result of findings by the National Commission on Severely Distressed Public Housing. HOPE VI called for demolishing and rebuilding public housing, with a goal of creating mixed-income communities.

HOPE VI also awarded competitive grants to local housing authorities that creatively address physical, social and fiscal problems. Detroit was chosen as a HOPE VI site in 1993 and received funds for the Jeffries West Homes, the Villages at Parkside and Herman Gardens. Approximately eight partners are working with Family Service to reduce poverty. Residents are receiving assistance in getting services they need to obtain and keep livable wage jobs.

Joyce Jordan Shaw, Associate Program Manager at FS, is working with families to link them to job and entrepreneurship training in career areas that include childcare, welding, manufacturing skills, and other trades.

“One of the main barriers to residents achieving self-sufficiency is their limited education levels, which restricts their job opportunities,” commented Shaw. “They need exposure to skills and training, even learning how to complete a resume, so they can get good-paying jobs.”

Both Shaw and consultant Fletcher see other obstacles that are holding back families from self-sufficiency.

 “Some of the clients are second-generation public housing residents. Because they’ve been living there for years, they don’t always realize the need to become self-sufficient,” observed Shaw. “We help them realize it’s time to help yourself.”

What these families need most is to realize they need help, according to Simmons. “Pride gets in the way. They allow things to happen to them and they wait until it’s too late,” she said.

The culture of dependency is passed on among generations, Fletcher has found. “Those who have become accustomed to receiving assistance may never develop the skills to be independent. It is important for families to achieve self-sufficiency, because the type and form of assistance they have been receiving may no longer be available,” added Fletcher, who has master’s degrees in community economic development and historic preservation.

Another stumbling block for families is lack of transportation, as well as unfamiliarity with the agencies that can help them. As in the case of Simmons, counseling and encouragement is important in achieving self-sufficiency.

“We work to motivate clients and instill in them self-esteem, so they will pursue opportunities,” explained Shaw.

HOPE VI is also dedicated to helping residents achieve the dream of owning a home. Construction of 245 duplexes, triplexes and townhouses is underway at Jeffries Homes, now called Woodbridge Estates. Groundbreaking was in April 2002. Development plans also call for an additional 101 homes to be built around the site, for public housing residents, renters and buyers.

“Many programs include home ownership as the pinnacle. This is fine, as long as the work has been done to bring people to the point of wanting. . . to assume the responsibilities that attend home ownership,” remarked Fletcher.

Whatever the path taken to achieve self-sufficiency, the payoff is significant for families and communities.

“When you’re able to pay your bills from wages you’ve earned and have a choice of where you want to live – that’s self-sufficiency,” commented Shaw.

“Family members may discover . . . creativity they never knew. They will be viewed as contributing to society,” said Fletcher. “And communities may be protected from some of the dysfunction that many times accompanies a culture of poverty and dependence.”

For Simmons, who is close to completing the purchase of a home, self-sufficiency has meant “being able to hold your own under pressure and being able to do it with the right attitude . . . being an overcomer.”  

back to Member Highlights page